PGH Insurance is where you matter most.
PGH Insurance Group LLC is your locally owned and operated Independent Insurance Agency in Lebanon, IN. Our main goal is to protect you and what matters most to you. The home you live in, the automobile you drive, the business you have built, and the life you live. Your Insurance needs are unique, and we have the competitive line up to meet those needs.
Meet Our Team
Started his Insurance career with PGH in 2016. He grew up in Jamestown and attended Western Boone High School where he was a leader on the football, basketball, and track teams. Tom went on to earn his Bachelors Degree in history from Wabash College. He also had the opportunity to play collegiate football for 4 years at Wabash – GO ‘BASH!
Tom is involved with the Boone County 4-H bicycle project where he is a co-leader with his Brother and Father. He is a member of the coaching staff for the Western Boone High School football team. In his free time, he enjoys working on project vehicles with his Dad, and cheering on the Little Giants at the annual Monon Bell football game.
“For Insurance Clarity… Call Tom Garrity “
Customer Service Representative
Debbie grew up in Zionsville, and then attended Hanover College and IUPUI. Debbie’s first career was as a Marsh Supermarket employee. Debbie worked as office bookkeeper and then General Merchandise Manager. The career switch to United States Postal Service as a city carrier in Lebanon started a new adventure. After 11 years of carrying mail, Debbie became a clerk and then eventually the lead clerk. After 25 years with postal service and a four month retirement, Debbie started employment with PGH Insurance October 2019. Within the first few weeks Debbie was a licensed agent. Always a “people person” Debbie enjoys the interaction with our customers.
Outside of work Debbie spends time with her husband, enjoys tending to the flower beds, and walking Yogi, their cute doggie. Debbie attends Grace Church in Lebanon, and helps out with the VBS Registration Carnival.
Taylor E Peycha
Customer Service Representative
Taylor is friendly, ambitious, and hopes to make your experience with PGH enjoyable! She attended Lebanon High School and later graduated from Marian University with a bachelor’s degree in Business Management in 2015. Taylor began her insurance career as a summer intern at a local agency during her junior and senior year of college. After graduation, Taylor obtained her Indiana insurance producer’s license and was hired as a licensed CSR at the same agency. In 2017, Taylor accepted a position with the Indiana Department of Insurance as an insurance investigator, deepening her understand of insurance laws in the state of Indiana. However, Taylor is excited to be “back in the field” as a licensed CSR with PGH.
Taylor resides in the community she serves with her husband, their 2 sons, and Great Dane. While not at work, she enjoys attending or hosting murder mystery dinners and game nights, spending time with friends and family, watching movies, and raising her children to appreciate geek culture like her and her husband.
Anthony started his tenure at PGH in 2019. He has been serving clients’ insurance needs for nearly 20 years. Anthony comes to Lebanon by way of Sydney, Australia, moving here when he was 10. Anthony is a Certified Professional Insurance Agent (CPIA), has owned and operated grocery stores as well as his own insurance agency for many years, s o he knows the struggles of owning and operating a business.
He loves being an Independent Agent, serving clients through many individual insurance carriers. He haslived in Boone and Hendricks Counties for 40 years, graduating from Lebanon High School and is an active member of the community.
Anthony currently lives in Lizton with his wife, Heidi, and six Chihuahuas! They have 5 children and 1 granddaughter. He is an active member of Restoration Church in Lebanon, loves gardening, muscle cars and spending time with family and friends.
Anthony writes all lines of Personal and Commercial insurance, Life Insurance, and Farm policies. If you need your home and auto covered, life insurance for you and your family members, or your farm or business protected, he will give you honest advice with integrity and professional, personalized service. Give him a call or email today.
Commercial & Farm Specialist
An experienced customer service representative, Shirley has been part of the service team since 1999.
Shirley and her daughter stay busy participating in 4H.
PGH Insurance Group LLC is dedicated to customer satisfaction. We provide competitive proposals with the proper coverage and experienced advice. Price is key, and we will explain what you are paying for. It’s not a matter of “If” but “When” something bad will happen.
Building the relationship with our customers is very important to us. Communicating questions that need to be asked and learning more about the customers’ needs is something we take pride in. Our line of carriers is second to none. We have a place for all your insurance needs and emphasize value over price.
Quality line of carriers
Service is our #1 priority.
Please contact us for a free comprehensive review of your current policy.
Or you can contact us for any new policies that are needed.
123 E Main St,
Lebanon, Indiana 46052